Toxic Worker Study

Management experts Michael Housman and Dylan Minor shared their research via a Harvard Business School working paper on people who are difficult to work with (referred to as "toxic workers" in their study).

Link to Study

One of the major findings: Don't hire them.

But many people know how to interview extremely well. The authors offered some toxic worker characteristics that I believe could be used during the application reviews, interviews, and reference checks:

Toxic worker characteristics:
1. Fanatical about rules
2. Outproduce normal workers but quality of work is lower
3. Overrate their abilities
4. Lack awareness of their impact on others

(Hey The Office fans, sound familiar?)

Perhaps if we were more intentional about searching for all of these characteristics in a candidate it can serve as a red flag to help us continue to reevaluate him or her during the hiring process.

Depending on the industry sector, once a part of the system some of these people can be difficult to let go. The ”solution" is often all too common -- they get shuffled to different departments, divisions, units, etc., leaving a wake of destruction everywhere they go unless there's an exceptional leader to manage and buffer their negative influence but what an abundance (and waste) of time and energy that takes!

In terms of higher education, it has been interesting to see the dynamics in committees and workgroups as campuses attempt transformational change. In general, the dynamics can be broken down into two types of people: talkers vs doers. Talkers tend to exhibit the characteristics noted above. They also hide behind archaic structures, processes, and comfortable routines they've established for themselves. In addition, talkers are typically unfazed about embarrassingly low student success and equity data. When they take control, the status quo is maintained and students end up paying the price.

Doers challenge the status quo and actually do some work. The work won't always be perfect but that's OK. Doers need to thoughtfully plan, execute, and make adjustments as they go. For campuses to be productive places of learning for students, they must also be for the educators! Change happens through the work!

Lastly, there's actually a third group: the quiet ones. If talkers succeed in thwarting all efforts to improve student outcomes, the quiet ones effectively become enablers.


Contact me about customized trainings or ongoing coaching support to help your campus plan and implement grants, projects, or comprehensive efforts such as guided pathways.  Use the contact form on the right (bottom of the page for mobile users).


Dr. Al's collaborative and inclusive leadership style is highly effective. His facilitation of our 3-day Guided Pathways summit was highly engaging. It propelled our work and his continued coaching support has ensured that we maintain a steady momentum. Marie Vicario-Fisher, Southwestern College Faculty, Health Science & Environmental Technology, Former Acting Special Assistant to the President, Guided Pathways

We continue to renew Dr. Al's services because we appreciate his value. He understands and genuinely appreciates shared governance and the critical roll faculty play in shaping Guided Pathways. He brings an array of tools, resources, and coaching skills that are tremendously valuable to our work. We engage with him extensively and he makes himself available at a moment's notice. The level of communication is unparalleled. Dr. Martha McDonald, Citrus College Vice-President, Student Services

Dr. Al helped secure two NSF grants that support our STEM meta-major. He listens to our needs and is an effective communicator and consensus builder. Dr. Par Mohammadian, Los Angeles Mission College Faculty, Life Science Vice Chair/Allied Health Director/NSF PI

Dr. Al provided us with exceptionally well-received customized trainings based on our needs. Our "why, what, how" of Guided Pathways session helped us create the planning structure that best suited us to move forward. In addition, he helped plan and conduct a student panel that helped to give additional meaning to the subsequent meta-major sorting activity with faculty and staff that he facilitated. We appreciate his approach of planning and executing with us instead of to us. Dr. Mary-Jo Apigo, West Los Angeles College, Dean of Teaching & Learning

We were recently awarded a 2.7M Title V STEM grant and have experienced a smooth transition from proposal to implementation. Dr. Al took us through a highly collaborative process to ensure all voices were heard. I highly recommend him for any project. He knows how to help campuses build clarity, coherence, and consensus.
Dr. Erik Bender, Orange Coast College Faculty, Geology & Title V Project Director

Our campus participated in a regional integrated planning workshop that Dr. Al led. We were so impressed with the session that we invited him to Diablo Valley College to assist us with integrated planning and Guided Pathways trainings. He didn't disappoint! Don't expect a "sit and get" session with him. He'll facilitate groups to do productive and meaningful work. It says a lot about his abilities when he can keep a group motivated and engaged from morning until the end of the day! Dr. Mark Akiyama, Diablo Valley College Faculty, Psychology & Chair, Student Equity Committee

(A. Solano)

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Copyright © Continuous Learner. Designed by OddThemes